I think attitude is best handled by on a regent by regent basis - that is, only one attitude per prpovince for a given regent, which keeps landed regents from having to make 2 attitude checks for every province (1 for land, 1 for law). Just use holdings as modifiers to actions, not the actual target of an attitude check. In BR we are most concerned about the character regents, not the organizations.

If we're talking about regents, then we need to decide:
1. Does a regent need to determine loyalty province by province or realm by realm?

2. Should all non-source regents check attitude by province or by realm?

3. Should source regents have attitude checks as well? What about in provinces where they have virtual guilds?

The discussion here is good, but these are pretty quantifiable concepts (can be polled), esp. #1 and 2. No. 3 is really more pthere for discussions' sake, 'cause no one's really mentioned it.

Osprey