As I've been setting up my pbem, I've worked out the GB collection for various levels of holdings, rounded down to the nearest 1/2 GB. Might be of use to people out there.

LEVEL.....LAW.......GUILD/TEMPLE
1.............0 GB.......0.5 GB
2.............0.5 GB....1 GB
3.............1 GB.......2 GB
4.............1 GB.......2.5 GB
5.............1.5.........3 GB
6.............2 GB.......4 GB
7.............2 GB.......4.5 GB
8.............2.5 GB.....5 GB
9.............3 GB........6 GB
10...........3 GB........6.5 GB

As these collections are a little lower than were expected during the original rules, I'm using the following optional rule.
+0.5 GB to guild and temple collection in provinces of level 4-5
+1 GB to guild and temple collections in province of level 6-7
+1.5 GB to guild and temple collection in provinces of level 8-9
+2 GB to guild and temple collection in provinces of level 10+

That brings it a little closer to the original.

For example: A level 5 holding in a level 5 province used to collect up to 6 GB, now it collects 3 which is about right, but a level 1 holding in a level 5 province used to collect 1-2 GB, but now collects only 0.5. Adding the +0.5 GB bonus, would give the level 5 holding a collection of 3.5 GB, and the level 1 holding 1 GB, which is about the same as the old average collection.

comments?