4ed is a good game, but a few things prevent me from playing it:

- unfortunately it has moved in a direction where it focuses more on tactical mastery of the combat rules than any other thing; which is completely uninteresting to me
- the flavor of the thing, ranging from the artwork to the whole concept of we're-fighting-superheroes; also not interesting
- some stuff got overly simplified (such as the skill selection) and I think the PCs all end up too alike

Hmmm, come to think of it I enjoy the Saga Edition of SW because it is simple and helps keep focus on the story; and Saga has many 4ish elements, but a lot less focus on tacticery and minis, so I'd say that 4ed COULD be made to work for me...I'm sure I could rewrite the whole game...but then it would not be DnD 4ed anymore