Results 21 to 30 of 97
Thread: Temples, Alignment, and Paladins
-
05-15-2007, 03:10 AM #21
- Join Date
- Jan 2006
- Posts
- 124
- Downloads
- 0
- Uploads
- 0
I hadn`t thought of it that way...good point.
The only counter I would have to that is that True
Wizards are very rare in Birthright...but anyone with
sufficient wisdom can call upon the Gods and be a
Cleric or Druid...anyone at all.
I`ve seen a ruler in Medeore demand that all
sufficiently wise men and women must be ordained to
the priesthood of Ruornil...something he had a hard
time implementing of course, but never the less it
proved in that game that clerics easily out-matched
wizards in general (realm magic excluded) simply due
to numbers. Just as the humans proved to the elves.
--- ryancaveney <brnetboard@BIRTHRIGHT.NET> wrote:
> ------------ QUOTE ----------
> none of us has ever seen the Pope speak
> with an angel any more than we have seen a wizard
> throw a fireball.
> -----------------------------
>
>
>
> And this, as I see it, is the crux of the matter.
> In D&D worlds, wizards perform miracles which are
> much flashier than those of priests, without any
> need to bring gods into the picture. You can even
> be a member of the priest class and simultaneously a
> vocal atheist, since all you need to do is
> acknowledge some abstract idea as the inspiration
> for your power. The ubiquity of magic in D&D makes
> miracles much less religious. Turning water into
> wine would be a big deal in the real world, but
> something you can get done at the corner drugstore
> in D&D. IMO, in a world where D&D magic was real,
> religion would be a whole lot less persuasive (or at
> least very different in content), because its claims
> to the supernatural would be merely humdrum.
>
>
> Ryan
>
>
>
> Birthright-l Archives:
> http://oracle.wizards.com/archives/birthright-l.html
> To unsubscribe, send email to
> LISTSERV@ORACLE.WIZARDS.COM
>
>
__________________________________________________ __________________________________Building a website is a piece of cake. Yahoo! Small Business gives you all the tools to get online.
http://smallbusiness.yahoo.com/webhosting
-
05-15-2007, 02:20 PM #22
- Join Date
- Dec 2002
- Location
- Malden, MA
- Posts
- 761
- Downloads
- 2
- Uploads
- 0
This is a much bigger problem! A society with common priestly magic is NOT pre-industrial in a large number of important ways. Military life changes drastically, too: food creation and preservation spells render sieges impossible -- you must take castles by assault, because the defenders will never succumb to starvation or disease. Mages who fly and cast fireballs make conventional armies nearly obsolete, anyway. A society with lots of magic is in many ways similar to a highly technological one, and it is these effects of the magic system which have never been properly considered. A social system based on non-spellcasting rulers with medieval armies and medieval castles simply cannot survive D&D magic. To keep the right flavor, drastic changes to the magic system are necessary to even attain some degree of suspension of disbelief.
Universal access to the priest class is in fact the single biggest demographic headache possible: there simply must be some mechanism which prevents people joining up, because otherwise every single peasant would be insane not to take levels in the class, precisely in order to gain access to the magic you describe. My solution in birthright is to make the same distinction between blooded and non-blooded priests as is made between blooded wizards and non-blooded magicians. IMC, you have to have a bloodline to be able to cure wounds or disease or any of the standard D&D cleric stuff -- commoners can cast only illusion and divination, and the stat requirements for being able to do even that are tightened significantly.
-
05-15-2007, 02:33 PM #23
- Join Date
- Dec 2002
- Location
- Malden, MA
- Posts
- 761
- Downloads
- 2
- Uploads
- 0
Anybody can have a code of behavior, make vows, etc., and many different philosophers and organizations offer suggested ones, but following, not following, or changing one never has any game mechanical effect. It can have profound social consequences, in terms of who chooses to associate with you, whether you go to prison, etc., but IMG codes of conduct are solely roleplaying hooks.
Paladins to me always (in my case, since 1980) seemed like merely a way to give humans access to the Fighter/Magic-User combination allowed to elves, half elves and such, but not to humans. Now that multiclassing is free for all, I see no reason it ought to exist as a separate class. It is precisely a combination of Fighter and Cleric, so it should be mechanic'ed simply by taking levels in each. Special stuff like the warhorse and laying on of hands is handled by spells, or junking it entirely.
Spells to detect alignment can give vague indications about personality (e.g., "this person is likely to follow the rules" or "this person has poor impulse control"), but never better than you can get just by talking to them for a few minutes. Spells to protect against or damage things based on alignment only apply to a few inherently magical creatures (awnsheghlien and ehrsheghlien in BR, some but not all extraplanar denizens in other campaign worlds). On the other hand, wizards are free to research "Protection from Goblins" or the like.
Ryan
-
05-15-2007, 02:51 PM #24
- Join Date
- Dec 2002
- Location
- Malden, MA
- Posts
- 761
- Downloads
- 2
- Uploads
- 0
Exactly the way it should be used, IMO. Personally, I prefer a different roleplaying shorthand, based on a popular personality theory in modern psychology (many of you in the working world may have been abused by a bad adaptiation of the Myers-Briggs/Keirsey version of Jungian type theory masquerading as the lastest in-thing for managers), but as a model of archetypes for listing what people find important, it's not all that bad. Of course, all nine descriptions as given in the text are of people who are so inflexible as to be clinically insane, but if you tone it down a few dozen decibels it can become a reasonable summary notation for NPC personality when you don't have time to develop a character in detail.
Exactly so! Its ONLY effects should be on the story, not the game rules.
I am a committed elf-lover (I've used the term "elfnocentrist" on this list before), and this aspect is the thing I like best about Cerilia. Enough of this whining about how good things used to be and retreating to distant shores -- form up the Gheallie Sidhe and go slaughter the forest-burning humans! My favorite scene in Peter Jackson's version of LOTR is when Frodo offers Galadriel the ring; I practically leap out of my chair, screaming, "Yes! Take the ring! Rule the world as a true descendant of Feanor should, scouring the lands clean of the foul orcs, cheating humans, and endlessly annoying hobbits!" I love the fact that in Cerilia, elves hate and kill humans. In my Cerilia, Rhuandice Tuarlachiem rules Tuarhievel, has already slaughtered every last human inhabitant of Cariele, and is annihilating her way through Thurazor towards Talinie and Boeruine. =>
Ryan
-
05-15-2007, 02:55 PM #25
- Join Date
- Dec 2002
- Location
- Malden, MA
- Posts
- 761
- Downloads
- 2
- Uploads
- 0
Hear, hear! Exactly how I use them.
I do, because in Cerilia, the most powerful magic-users are the atheist elves and the awnsheghlien. However, even though in my cosmology, the gods in fact do not exist, religion is still a supremely important social force among humans (indeed, all the species except elves) for precisely the reasons you indicate below:
Ryan
-
05-15-2007, 05:15 PM #26
One word...MEDICATION... Just kidding of course.
In regards to alignment again, I am working on a set of Virtues and Vices that players would select, say 7 or so (Seven Deadly sin thing I know I know) from a master list of about 12 virtues and 12 vices that would help you define your personality when building the the characters persona.
Not quite a robbery from Pendragon as the list would be role playing aids not a dice mechanic.
In regards to the classes with alignment requirements there would instead be a virtue/vice list.
Clerics and other prayer driven classes would have the Six Virtues/vices of their patron, plus one other that they could select that would accentuate or moderate their faith. (To keep the birthright flavor of Clerics not always being moral clones of their patron I would also allow them to substitute one of the Cardinal Virtue/Vices for another)
Spells that detect alignment would instead simply gauge how far apart two personas are in beleifs...say a sort of Aura reading.
In effect the only true Evil would be that of outsiders such as Demons and Devils and the like who of course have absolutely no redeeming "Anuirean" virtues. Of course then again I will need to do Virtues and Vices for every culture...sigh...
Still just working it out...
Just somthing I am playing around with.Last edited by Dcolby; 05-15-2007 at 05:38 PM.
Good Morning Peasant!!
-
05-15-2007, 06:52 PM #27
- Join Date
- Dec 2002
- Location
- Malden, MA
- Posts
- 761
- Downloads
- 2
- Uploads
- 0
-
05-15-2007, 07:40 PM #28
Thanx for the List...
I was basing my Virtues and Vices off a mixture of Roman and Western European examples to try and get an Anuirean feel.
Mercy VS Cruelty
Dignity (Selfworth/Pride) vs Unseemliness
Tenacity VS Cowardice
Respectability (Image) VS Indecency
Learning VS Ignorance
Industriousness VS Laziness
Self Control VS Decadence
Piety VS Impiety
Prudence VS Recklessness
Truthfulness VS Dishonesty
Frugalness VS Spendthrift
Duty VS Disloyalty
Of course Roman Mercy and Christian mercy concepts are very very different, but I think I have a good set of Anuirean core traits both good and bad.Last edited by Dcolby; 05-15-2007 at 07:44 PM.
Good Morning Peasant!!
-
05-15-2007, 08:15 PM #29
In LUG's Star Trek RPG, there were five core reputation areas, and each major affiliation (Federation, Romulan, Klingon, &c) had three that were required to make your next promotion.
Whenever discussing values, I think we need to focus on a combination of culture (Anuirean, Rjurik, Khinasi, Brecht, Vos, Dwarf, Elf, &c) and religion.
Ultimatly, a really cool reputation system would be as broad as the skill system, and probabaly like LUG's Star Trek, each culture would value a different set of reputation values, so that a character might have high reputation (be well known) but would be respected and admired differently depening on which culture he encounters.
A nice list of admired cultural values makes it easier to build a character that will be admired, or select the culture that matches the way you intend to play your character.
-
05-16-2007, 12:41 AM #30
The books do state what Boeruine's motives are. The Chamberlain (the father, not the son), the General, and Prince Fhilereane (to name a few, I don't want to go through the entire novel and footnote everyone) are very clear that he is a man who wishes power. Take into account that he allied with the Gorgon (not known to his allies) and he is a fiend lead by blind ambition.
There is no indication that he has a grievance with Hadrian except for the fact that when Hadrian dies, he won't be Emperor. His allies sided with him because he told them Michael was dead, and if Michael was dead he would be in the right and the Chamberlain opposing his getting the throne was in the wrong. That is why he had allies, and the Chamberlain had the IC (Avanil then Diemed joined after Michael re-surfaced.) He had the perfect plan to take back the throne. The fact that Michael resurfaced and was still alive was explained to his allies that obviously that wasn't Michael and a plot by the Sidhe (and since most of the realms bordered the Manslayer who sided with Boeruine, not something they wouldn't believe).
We know this. Nothing in the Iron Throne lends to the theory that there is a grievance. There is indicators that it was blind ambition, a man who was going to inherit the throne until Michael was born. I guess if he had a grievance it would be Michael's birth.
And for those fighting against the curse of Azrai, it is pointed out in Book Regency it couldn't be ignored, just slow down the inevitable. It even mentions that there is no one know who has been able to fight off its effects forever. The examples you give will eventually turn, and there is no evidence that Tara is "good" (no stats given) and the PS states she could potentially have another reason and it could be a trick by the Gorgon.
Thread Information
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Similar Threads
-
Avani Paladins
By The Jew in forum BRCS 3.0/3.5 EditionReplies: 32Last Post: 06-08-2004, 12:22 AM -
Paladins of Neserie
By Osprey in forum The Royal LibraryReplies: 12Last Post: 06-01-2004, 05:50 AM -
Paladins and Multiclassing
By Osprey in forum BRCS 3.0/3.5 EditionReplies: 28Last Post: 03-24-2004, 05:50 AM -
Clergy Alignment vs. God Alignment
By Azrai in forum The Royal LibraryReplies: 40Last Post: 07-02-2002, 10:10 AM
Bookmarks