Results 11 to 20 of 32
Thread: I feel it`s my duty (long as he
-
02-26-1999, 11:51 AM #11
- Join Date
- Nov 2001
- Location
- Nether-Netherland
- Posts
- 308
- Downloads
- 0
- Uploads
- 0
I feel it`s my duty (long as he
> Further, BR is the first setting that I have seen give any real
> treatment to the human race besides saying "they're the dominant".
It is indeed this aspect that made me and my players turn away from FR and
delve into BR. Plus the facts that BR has a far better set atmosphere
than FR will ever have with its anything-goes demeanor and that BR
succeeds in providing a system that makes playing a PC ruler actually
interesting, among other things.
Nothing but praise... Well, except for the modules, of course. :)
- the Falcon
-
02-26-1999, 06:19 PM #12Eric L. BoydGuest
I feel it`s my duty (long as he
Tim Nutting wrote:
> My difficulty with FR has always been the extreme level of power that
> seems to never do anything.
This comment struck me as somewhat ironic given the number of people who
complain that the Realms evolves too quickly and of the "excessive"
number of "Realms-shattering events" they see. :-)
In any event, to address your question: The world presented in the core
material of the Realms lays out an environment in which there are
numerous high-powered groups locked in a fierce detente with each other.
The PCs have the opportunity to shine by careful navigation through
those ever-skirmishing power groups, subtly shifting the status quo if
they are skilled in their dealings with various NPCs.
Is this the only way to play the Realms? No. Is this the only way to
structure a "good" campaign? Of course not. However, it can be quite fun
and give the players a chance to shine as heroes without feeling like
they are the most powerful people on the continent.
> I couldn't even tell you what the main branch of the human gene pool
> is in Faerun.
While it is not played up as much as in Birthright or Greyhawk, the
Realms has numerous human groups whose migrations have crisscrossed the
continent. Some of the ethnic groups of the core Realms which come to
mind off the top of my head include:
Tethen
Calishite
Chultan
Turami
Mulan
Imaskari
Neth
Rashemi
Rus
Uthgardt
Northmen
Ffolk
Ice Hunter
Shaaran
Although everyone has their likes and dislikes, one of the major
attractions of the Realms for its fans is the depth of the material
buried across various products. Just about any campaign tidbit you'd
like to find is "in there," with much of it just barely hinted at and
waiting to be developed by the DM. You just have to dig a little bit
sometimes.
Now back to your regularly scheduled BR discussion ...
- --Eric, a longtime lurker
- --
Eric L. Boyd
Unix Systems Group
boyd@zk3.dec.com
-
02-26-1999, 09:14 PM #13brandesGuest
I feel it`s my duty (long as he
>> Further, BR is the first setting that I have seen give any real
>> treatment to the human race besides saying "they're the dominant".
>
>It is indeed this aspect that made me and my players turn away from FR and
>delve into BR. Plus the facts that BR has a far better set atmosphere
>than FR will ever have with its anything-goes demeanor and that BR
>succeeds in providing a system that makes playing a PC ruler actually
>interesting, among other things.
>Nothing but praise... Well, except for the modules, of course. :)
>
> - the Falcon
Okay, this is exactly the kind of argument I was trying to STOP when I began
this thread. "Plus the facts that BR has a far better set atmosphere than
FR will ever have?" Um, gee, that sounds like a well-reasoned argument.
We're glad that you made up your mind on this, but I think many of us would
like to hear something a little more debatable.
Just so you know, FR was not designed for rulership. Neither was the rest
of AD&D. On the other hand, you may have seen my post several days ago with
advice on how to be a wise "regent" in Shadowdale.
Brandes
-
03-01-1999, 11:42 AM #14
- Join Date
- Nov 2001
- Location
- Nether-Netherland
- Posts
- 308
- Downloads
- 0
- Uploads
- 0
I feel it`s my duty (long as he
> Okay, this is exactly the kind of argument I was trying to STOP when I began
> this thread. "Plus the facts that BR has a far better set atmosphere than
> FR will ever have?" Um, gee, that sounds like a well-reasoned argument.
> We're glad that you made up your mind on this, but I think many of us would
> like to hear something a little more debatable.
> Just so you know, FR was not designed for rulership. Neither was the rest
> of AD&D. On the other hand, you may have seen my post several days ago with
> advice on how to be a wise "regent" in Shadowdale.
OK, what I mean by "a far better set atmosphere" is that while BR has a
very specific set of spells, monsters, magical items, etc. for it's
gameworld (which IMHO greatly defines the atmosphere), the FR can't seem
to get enough of those (IMHO greatly blurring the atmosphere). I think
the FR would greatly benefit from their contributers being more selective
and a bit less generic.
Better?
-
03-01-1999, 08:54 PM #15brandesGuest
I feel it`s my duty (long as he
>OK, what I mean by "a far better set atmosphere" is that while BR has a
>very specific set of spells, monsters, magical items, etc. for it's
>gameworld (which IMHO greatly defines the atmosphere), the FR can't seem
>to get enough of those (IMHO greatly blurring the atmosphere). I think
>the FR would greatly benefit from their contributers being more selective
>and a bit less generic.
>Better?
Very much so. I argue that FR does in fact have specific sets of spells . .
. defined along the lines of power groups. As was recently observed on this
mailing list, FR is a world consumed by conflict between mighty
organizations, nations, and societies. (Harpers, Red Wizards, Zhentarim,
Cult of the Dragon, Knights of the Shield, Twisted Rune, Heralds, Iron
Throne, etc.) Several of these groups have spells that are unique to them
and those they train. For example, the Seven Sisters have their own
sourcebook. This sourcebook has a full chapter on the spells unique to the
Seven Sisters and a select few others. The Red Wizards have their own
collection of spells, as do the Zhentarim, Cult of the Dragon, and others.
Occasionally, these spells leak out of their security by means of a lost or
stolen spellbook.
I can't make much of an argument regarding magic items, except that
artifacts are often identified with a specific group (such as the Crown of
Horns, which was defeated by Khelben, and the combination artifacts, the
Death Moon Orb and Thaksoril's Seat, which are controlled b Szass Tam.)
Does this help?
Brandes
PS. Something I'm curious about: Have you personally played FR
extensively, or are you going on stereotype? I'm not making an accusation
or anything; I'm just curious.
-
03-02-1999, 12:55 PM #16
- Join Date
- Nov 2001
- Location
- Nether-Netherland
- Posts
- 308
- Downloads
- 0
- Uploads
- 0
I feel it`s my duty (long as he
> Very much so. I argue that FR does in fact have specific sets of spells . .
> . defined along the lines of power groups. As was recently observed on this
> mailing list, FR is a world consumed by conflict between mighty
> organizations, nations, and societies. (Harpers, Red Wizards, Zhentarim,
> Cult of the Dragon, Knights of the Shield, Twisted Rune, Heralds, Iron
> Throne, etc.) Several of these groups have spells that are unique to them
> and those they train. For example, the Seven Sisters have their own
> sourcebook. This sourcebook has a full chapter on the spells unique to the
> Seven Sisters and a select few others. The Red Wizards have their own
> collection of spells, as do the Zhentarim, Cult of the Dragon, and others.
> Occasionally, these spells leak out of their security by means of a lost or
> stolen spellbook.
Well, I can't argue that FR has some pretty cool spells and magical
items. Some neat monsters as well. But a lot of it just lacks common
ground. They just don't share any connections. Plus, about any monster
from any other world (save perhaps Athas and Cerilia) can be found on the
Realms. Sometimes, it seems to me that FR just wants to have it all, but
ends up with a horribly mismatched collection of oddities, if you know
what I mean.
> I can't make much of an argument regarding magic items, except that
> artifacts are often identified with a specific group (such as the Crown of
> Horns, which was defeated by Khelben, and the combination artifacts, the
> Death Moon Orb and Thaksoril's Seat, which are controlled b Szass Tam.)
> Does this help?
I'd like to quote something from Spelljammer here (I don't have the books
with me, so please me excuse me for any lost words):
"The fact that groundlings aren't hip-deep in artifacts is that someone
has found a use for them: artifurnaces."
Artifurnaces aside, I think this quote pretty much says what I'm gainin
at.
> PS. Something I'm curious about: Have you personally played FR
> extensively, or are you going on stereotype? I'm not making an accusation
> or anything; I'm just curious.
I've played FR pretty extensively as a DM. My players more or less share
my opionion on the matter. We still plan to return to FR some time, but
not in the near future. I'm not sayin FR is a bad setting. It's just far
to all-encompassing for its own good.
- the Falcon
-
03-02-1999, 02:04 PM #17Gwaeron@aol.coGuest
I feel it`s my duty (long as he
In a message dated 3/2/99 7:58:21 AM Eastern Standard Time,
m.m.richert@twi.tudelft.nl writes:
> I'd like to quote something from Spelljammer here (I don't have the books
> with me, so please me excuse me for any lost words):
> "The fact that groundlings aren't hip-deep in artifacts is that someone
> has found a use for them: artifurnaces."
> Artifurnaces aside, I think this quote pretty much says what I'm gainin
> at.
Hmm, I could be mistaken, but that statement isn't totally correct. I'm
nowhere close to my books, but you never mentioned anything else about the
furnaces either. They aren't all that common, and to be honest, I've never
seen that quote in any shape, unless its in one of the few supplements I don't
have. Do you happen to know which one it is from?
-
03-02-1999, 08:58 PM #18brandesGuest
I feel it`s my duty (long as he
>I've played FR pretty extensively as a DM. My players more or less share
>my opionion on the matter. We still plan to return to FR some time, but
>not in the near future. I'm not sayin FR is a bad setting. It's just far
>to all-encompassing for its own good.
>
> - the Falcon
Well, FR isn't the only setting that TSR has produced that has attempted to
be a genereic world with simply an "undercurrent" to differentiate it from
others. I'm thinking specifically Greyhawk and Mystara here . . .
remembering that the geography of Greyhawk is REALLY all-encompassing, with
essentially everything thrown randomly together. Maybe it works; I haven't
played Greyhawk (GH?!?) but have seen a variety of maps and descriptions.
Brandes
-
03-02-1999, 11:06 PM #19Samuel WeissGuest
I feel it`s my duty (long as he
>I'm thinking specifically Greyhawk and Mystara here . . .
remembering that the geography of Greyhawk is REALLY all-encompassing, with
essentially everything thrown randomly together. Maybe it works; I haven't
played Greyhawk (GH?!?) but have seen a variety of maps and descriptions.
Brandes<
I think you have the two mixed up.
Mystara is an incredible random hodgepodge.
Greyhawk, while apparently geologically impossible, is not that random. It
is very wide ranging though. Although most of the action is centered on a
rather homogenous cultural region.
Samwise
-
03-03-1999, 10:54 AM #20Pieter SleijpenGuest
I feel it`s my duty (long as he
Samuel Weiss wrote:
>
> >I'm thinking specifically Greyhawk and Mystara here . . .
> remembering that the geography of Greyhawk is REALLY all-encompassing, with
> essentially everything thrown randomly together. Maybe it works; I haven't
> played Greyhawk (GH?!?) but have seen a variety of maps and descriptions.
>
> Brandes<
>
> I think you have the two mixed up.
> Mystara is an incredible random hodgepodge.
> Greyhawk, while apparently geologically impossible, is not that random. It
> is very wide ranging though. Although most of the action is centered on a
> rather homogenous cultural region.
>
> Samwise
Ever taken a look at Europe in the 14th century, that was a real mix bag
of different cultures, just like Mystara and often a simple border could
mean that difference. It is this large difference in cultures that makes
Mystara unique, while FR is one large bland. Lets be honest, a citizen
of Waterdeep would not have any problems with culture in Cormyr, while
both nations are very far from each other. A citizen of Darokin, would
have a lot more trouble in Thyatis or even Karameikos.
Pieter Sleijpen
Thread Information
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Similar Threads
-
Long bow
By Sorontar in forum MainReplies: 0Last Post: 01-31-2010, 09:33 AM -
Threads i feel that need to be added.
By Aldrin in forum Birthright.net supportReplies: 9Last Post: 11-09-2007, 02:35 AM -
Novels with a BR feel?
By Eyeless One in forum The Royal LibraryReplies: 14Last Post: 05-28-2004, 04:42 AM -
I feel it`s my duty
By brandes in forum MPGN Mailinglist archive 1996-1999Replies: 7Last Post: 02-24-1999, 03:39 PM -
RE: Guns (long)
By Jim Paterson in forum MPGN Mailinglist archive 1996-1999Replies: 0Last Post: 09-01-1998, 08:06 AM
Bookmarks