Results 1 to 2 of 2
  1. #1
    David Sean Brown
    Guest

    [BIRTHRIGHT] Mult- and Dual

    > > > Say you're a lawyer who has passed the BAR but before you begin your
    > > career you
    > > > decide to become a doctor, so you drop your briefs and start studying
    > > anatomy.
    > > > (Sorry, couldn't resist the underwear joke.) In an AD&D world after you
    > > pass your
    > > > residency and start practicing you could start acting like a lawyer
    > > again, right?
    > > > Why couldn't you decide to drop your doctoring, go back to law and start
    > > gaining
    > > > experience in that profession again? Why couldn't you be a
    > > lawyer-doctor? (I
    > > > actually know one of these guys in real life, so it's not impossible.)

    Why couldn't you do this? Sure its not impossible, but lets do a bit of
    math here just to show some numbers:

    Suppose you graduate from HIgh school at 18
    4 years of undergraduate University puts you at 22 years old
    So you go to Law school now..3 more years..25
    article for 2 years, and pass the bar...27
    You then go through 4 years of med school..31 years old
    Now you have to do your residency...suppose you don't specialize, then
    only 2 more years...you are 33 years old and can practice...not sure what
    the rules are in the states, but here in canada, you now have to do a
    minimum number of continuing education hours a year in order to keep
    practicing..keep this in mind..
    Of course, by this time your debt load is some enourmous number you really
    don't want to even hear it (you are looking well over 6 figures in the
    hole..) and you are 33 years old..hope you didn't want a family cause you
    don't have a lot of time.
    Now you practice for a while and tehn decide you want to be a lawyer at
    the same time...well, you still have to keep up your CME credits, and work
    a minimum number of hours to look after your patient (after all, you ahve
    a billing number, so you are expected to work as a physician...)

    You are also 6 years out from having done anything like law..do you think
    you are as good now as you were then? Not likely...try to think of
    something you used to do 6 years ago that required a fair amoout of
    knowledge or skill that you haven't done since then..how do you think you
    would do?

    The point is, while t is possible, it is EXTREMELY difficult...the AD&D
    system reflects this in a way, while attempting to maintain game balance
    (after all, you could just keep switching back and forth between character
    classes, and end up with some sort of God-mortal)..just doesn't work very
    well..

  2. #2
    Gary V. Foss
    Guest

    [BIRTHRIGHT] Mult- and Dual

    David Sean Brown wrote:

    > > > > Say you're a lawyer who has passed the BAR but before you begin your
    > > > career you
    > > > > decide to become a doctor, so you drop your briefs and start studying
    > > > anatomy.
    > > > > (Sorry, couldn't resist the underwear joke.) In an AD&D world after you
    > > > pass your
    > > > > residency and start practicing you could start acting like a lawyer
    > > > again, right?
    > > > > Why couldn't you decide to drop your doctoring, go back to law and start
    > > > gaining
    > > > > experience in that profession again? Why couldn't you be a
    > > > lawyer-doctor? (I
    > > > > actually know one of these guys in real life, so it's not impossible.)
    >
    > Why couldn't you do this? Sure its not impossible, but lets do a bit of
    > math here just to show some numbers:
    >
    > Suppose you graduate from HIgh school at 18
    > 4 years of undergraduate University puts you at 22 years old
    > So you go to Law school now..3 more years..25
    > article for 2 years, and pass the bar...27
    > You then go through 4 years of med school..31 years old
    > Now you have to do your residency...suppose you don't specialize, then
    > only 2 more years...you are 33 years old and can practice...not sure what
    > the rules are in the states, but here in canada, you now have to do a
    > minimum number of continuing education hours a year in order to keep
    > practicing..keep this in mind..
    > Of course, by this time your debt load is some enourmous number you really
    > don't want to even hear it (you are looking well over 6 figures in the
    > hole..) and you are 33 years old..hope you didn't want a family cause you
    > don't have a lot of time.

    Oh, God. Thanks for depressing me. I'm thirty-two and unmarried and still paying
    off my college loans. Thanks for the pep talk, babe. You're worse than my
    mother....

    > Now you practice for a while and tehn decide you want to be a lawyer at
    > the same time...well, you still have to keep up your CME credits, and work
    > a minimum number of hours to look after your patient (after all, you ahve
    > a billing number, so you are expected to work as a physician...)
    >
    > You are also 6 years out from having done anything like law..do you think
    > you are as good now as you were then? Not likely...try to think of
    > something you used to do 6 years ago that required a fair amoout of
    > knowledge or skill that you haven't done since then..how do you think you
    > would do?

    Just like ridin' a bike, man. I know too many lawyers to think it's THAT hard....

    > The point is, while t is possible, it is EXTREMELY difficult...the AD&D
    > system reflects this in a way, while attempting to maintain game balance
    > (after all, you could just keep switching back and forth between character
    > classes, and end up with some sort of God-mortal)..just doesn't work very
    > well..

    Would things be made even worse if I explained that my friend is also a CPA?
    Really. He is. Brains are just squirting out of this guy's head like watermelon
    at a Gallagher concert. He's got more sheepskin on his walls than the Big Bad
    Wolf....

    A few points:

    The lawyer-doctor comparison was a RL example that is good as far as it goes, but
    breaks down pretty quickly when you tone things down to the AD&D equivalent of
    "professional" fighters, thieves, wizards and priests. Oh, there's a certain
    amount of education that one has to go through in order to become a "professional"
    in gaming terms, but nothing like that of my lawyer-doctor-accountant friend. It
    takes a year of study to become a 1st level wizard at the College of Sorcery.
    Another two to become 3rd level. Using that 1:1 basis for study and experience,
    my friend would be a 4th level accountant (his undergrad major) a 3+ level lawyer
    (I don't know if article for 2 years counts as study or experience) and a 4+ level
    doctor (same thing for residency.) That's not bad. But if he chose to simple do
    the accelorated one year course and then go about the business of adventuring he'd
    be able to switch classes pretty quickly, and probably gain experience levels much
    more quickly.

    This is one of the weaknesses of the dual-class rules. How much studying does it
    take to switch class? From the rules you think you could do it just as quick as
    turning on a lightswitch. I have a house rule that PCs who switch class actually
    begin at 0-level and have to work up to first, thereby giving at least the
    illusion that they had to go through a process of learning first.

    Another house rule: I don't like the flat rate 10% exp. bonus for high ability
    scores. The difference between a 16 and an 18 is pretty big in game terms (and
    odds) so why not have something a little more reflective of how ability and
    experience relate to one another? Players get prime req - 5 as a bonus to
    experience in my campaigns. That is a thief with a 17 dex gets a 12% bonus.
    Character classes with more than one prime requisite average them and subtract
    five to get their bonus number. This also gives most PCs different experience
    point totals and makes everyone unique in a party that often gets group experience
    point awards.

    Gary

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads

  1. [BIRTHRIGHT] Mult- and Dual-cla
    By Gary V. Foss in forum MPGN Mailinglist archive 1996-1999
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 09-04-1998, 10:17 PM
  2. dual-class in birthright
    By John in forum MPGN Mailinglist archive 1996-1999
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 04-26-1998, 07:32 PM
  3. Dual-class exp restrictions.
    By Rasmus Juul Wagner in forum MPGN Mailinglist archive 1996-1999
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 03-09-1998, 11:40 AM
  4. dual classing...
    By rad smith in forum MPGN Mailinglist archive 1996-1999
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 03-07-1998, 07:33 PM
  5. RE: dual classing...
    By jonathan.w.ingram@exgate in forum MPGN Mailinglist archive 1996-1999
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 03-05-1998, 08:57 PM

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
BIRTHRIGHT, DUNGEONS & DRAGONS, D&D, the BIRTHRIGHT logo, and the D&D logo are trademarks owned by Wizards of the Coast, Inc., a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc., and are used by permission. ©2002-2010 Wizards of the Coast, Inc.