Page 3 of 3 FirstFirst 123
Results 21 to 26 of 26
  1. #21
    E Gray
    Guest

    Everybodys Favorte: Elves

    - -----Original Message-----
    From: LordSchmit
    To: birthright@MPGN.COM
    Date: Wednesday, March 11, 1998 8:49 AM
    Subject: Re: [BIRTHRIGHT] - Everybodys Favorte: Elves


    >>now what I REALLY hate in the PHB is the way elves seems to
    >>go to a land far across the oceans or something instead of die of old
    age..
    >>UGGH!!! Immortal, ok, long-lived ok, but this? NO!NO!NO!NO!
    >
    >Don't the FR elves go off to Evermeet or where ever? (I know very little
    about
    >the Realms, but I read that somewhere).

    Yes, they can go there, but the elves of the FR didn't always, in fact a lot
    probably did die of old age....can't recall exactly when Evermeet was
    settled, but it wasn't that recent....in any case Tolkein is the one to
    blame
    not Greenwood.

    > FR seems to be the only AD&D published
    >world that goes by that "go away to a far off island instead of dying"
    thing
    >the PHB says elves do.


    But that's more of a get away from the horrible humans and live the rest of
    our lives in peace thing.

  2. #22
    E Gray
    Guest

    Everybodys Favorte: Elves

    - -----Original Message-----
    From: Samuel Weiss
    To: birthright@MPGN.COM
    Date: Wednesday, March 11, 1998 9:00 AM
    Subject: Re: [BIRTHRIGHT] - Everybodys Favorte: Elves


    >>now what I REALLY hate in the PHB is the way elves seems to
    >go to a land far across the oceans or something instead of die of old age..
    >UGGH!!! Immortal, ok, long-lived ok, but this? NO!NO!NO!NO!<


    >We went over this very topic on Greytalk awhile back. And most everyone
    >there pretty much felt this was an evil influence from the FR that all good
    >AD&Ders should ignore completely

    The FR? Hmm, Yes, the Elven culture is going away to Evermeet but
    I think elves still die of old age normally, they're just trying to escape
    humanity and live out their years in peace......besides Tolkein is the one
    to blame for the idea, not Greenwood.


    >So if you do have
    >mortal elves in your game, dig out an old DMG and the age tables for elves
    >therein.


    Why? There's a perfectly good table in the 2nd Edition PHB, it's just the
    little note at the bottom you have to ignore....

  3. #23
    Mark A Vandermeulen
    Guest

    Everybodys Favorte: Elves

    On Wed, 11 Mar 1998, Gary V. Foss wrote:

    > Anyway, as far as elves sailing off into the West is concerned. I think
    > Tolkien meant is as more of a retirement kind of concept rather than as a form
    > of death. Gandalf, Bilbo and Frodo get to go along too, remember? So it can't
    > be just for elves. Maybe it was just a symbolic way of saying "I don't want to
    > write about these characters anymore, but I don't have the heart to snuff them,
    > so I'm going to send them on a long cruise."
    >
    > It's kind of a cop-out that works much more effectively to end a story than it
    > does in a RPG.

    I don't think it was a cop-out at all. The while point of elves sailing
    off to the west (for anyone who actually slogged through the Silmarillion)
    is that the West (I can't remember the name) IS heaven. When the elves are
    sailing off to the west, they are going to heaven only without dieing
    first (like Elijah in the Old Testament). Only elves can do this. The path
    to the western land was closed off to humans: they can only get there
    through death. I think if it sort of like God taking earth, which was
    formerly flat, and making it into a sphere, only part of it was left out,
    and that is the part where the elves go: they actually leave the earth and
    sail to "heaven" in some sort of mysterious, mystic way. Gandalf could do
    this because he wasn't human (he was actually more like a kind of
    earth-bound angel), and Frodo could go because he bore the Ring, which
    left its mark on him. Samwise appears to have gone the same way, and for
    the same reason. The only one who I don't really understand is Gimli,
    which the appendix says sailed off to the West with Legolas. Perhaps he
    just died in the end, but wanted to go with Legolas his friend for as much
    of the way as possible.

    Gosh that was fun. I haven't debated Middle-Earth theology in ages. :)

    Mark VanderMeulen
    vander+@pitt.edu

  4. #24
    Samuel Weiss
    Guest

    Everybodys Favorte: Elves

    >I don't think it was a cop-out at all. The while point of elves sailing
    off to the west (for anyone who actually slogged through the Silmarillion)
    is that the West (I can't remember the name) IS heaven. When the elves are
    sailing off to the west, they are going to heaven only without dieing
    first (like Elijah in the Old Testament). Only elves can do this. The path
    to the western land was closed off to humans: they can only get there
    through death. I think if it sort of like God taking earth, which was
    formerly flat, and making it into a sphere, only part of it was left out,
    and that is the part where the elves go: they actually leave the earth and
    sail to "heaven" in some sort of mysterious, mystic way. Gandalf could do
    this because he wasn't human (he was actually more like a kind of
    earth-bound angel), and Frodo could go because he bore the Ring, which
    left its mark on him. Samwise appears to have gone the same way, and for
    the same reason. The only one who I don't really understand is Gimli,
    which the appendix says sailed off to the West with Legolas. Perhaps he
    just died in the end, but wanted to go with Legolas his friend for as much
    of the way as possible.

    Gosh that was fun. I haven't debated Middle-Earth theology in ages. :)

    Mark VanderMeulen
    vander+@pitt.edu<

    "slogged" through the Silmarillion? Watch youself, that borders on heresy.
    The elves were invited to go live with the Valar in the West. They left
    because of the Silmarils. They were allowed to go back when they repented
    their choice in leaving. Humans were never invited in the first place,
    mostly because of their mortality. bear in mind though, that an elf that
    dies goes to the Halls of the dead. They don't get brought back to life to
    hang out with the other elves and the Valar. Gandalf was more of an avatar
    of a Demi-Power, though I suppose you could see that as an earth bound
    angel as well. Frodo and Samwise (The greatest character ever) did indeed
    get to go to the West along with Bilbo because they were Ringbearers. Gimli
    wanted to see Galadriel again, and because of her influence he was able to
    get in. It doesn't actuallly say whether Giml kicks off after going over
    and seeing her though.

    Samwise

  5. #25
    Junior Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2001
    Location
    San Francisco, CA
    Posts
    10
    Downloads
    0
    Uploads
    0

    Everybodys Favorte: Elves

    >now what I REALLY hate in the PHB is the way elves seems to
    >go to a land far across the oceans or something instead of die of old age..
    >UGGH!!! Immortal, ok, long-lived ok, but this? NO!NO!NO!NO!

    According to the elven handbook, when elves reac venerable age, they feel the
    urge to retreat from the mortal world and join the Seldrine in Arvandor. The
    intial "go off to a far away land" was meant as a tempory solution to elven
    immortality before TSR got around to publishing the elven handbook.

    And to reply to lord shade's comment about evermeet, No. Evermeet is the
    last kindom of elves left on toril, but when they still reach old age they
    leave that plane of existance and journey to meet the Seldrine. That is why
    elves have such a strong racial identiy, after they all die they end up in the
    same place to be reborn into the next generation.

    Thanks for listening, those are my two pences.

    Cedyeus

  6. #26
    Gary V. Foss
    Guest

    Everybodys Favorte: Elves

    Mark A Vandermeulen wrote:

    > On Wed, 11 Mar 1998, Gary V. Foss wrote:
    >
    > > Anyway, as far as elves sailing off into the West is concerned. I think
    > > Tolkien meant is as more of a retirement kind of concept rather than as a form
    > > of death. Gandalf, Bilbo and Frodo get to go along too, remember? So it can't
    > > be just for elves. Maybe it was just a symbolic way of saying "I don't want to
    > > write about these characters anymore, but I don't have the heart to snuff them,
    > > so I'm going to send them on a long cruise."
    > >
    > > It's kind of a cop-out that works much more effectively to end a story than it
    > > does in a RPG.
    >
    > I don't think it was a cop-out at all. The while point of elves sailing
    > off to the west (for anyone who actually slogged through the Silmarillion)
    > is that the West (I can't remember the name) IS heaven. When the elves are
    > sailing off to the west, they are going to heaven only without dieing
    > first (like Elijah in the Old Testament). Only elves can do this. The path
    > to the western land was closed off to humans: they can only get there
    > through death. I think if it sort of like God taking earth, which was
    > formerly flat, and making it into a sphere, only part of it was left out,
    > and that is the part where the elves go: they actually leave the earth and
    > sail to "heaven" in some sort of mysterious, mystic way. Gandalf could do
    > this because he wasn't human (he was actually more like a kind of
    > earth-bound angel), and Frodo could go because he bore the Ring, which
    > left its mark on him. Samwise appears to have gone the same way, and for
    > the same reason. The only one who I don't really understand is Gimli,
    > which the appendix says sailed off to the West with Legolas. Perhaps he
    > just died in the end, but wanted to go with Legolas his friend for as much
    > of the way as possible.
    >
    > Gosh that was fun. I haven't debated Middle-Earth theology in ages. :)
    >
    > Mark VanderMeulen
    > vander+@pitt.edu

    Gimli and Legolas were lovers. JOKE! It's a joke! I'm only joking!

    OK, maybe my characterization of Tolkien was a little harsh. What I was trying to
    say, though, was that sailing off to the West was the kind of thing that works better
    in a novel format than in a RPG, so putting it in FR was kind of clumsy, IMO.

    - -G.

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads

  1. Elves
    By Bearcat in forum Category
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 05-03-2020, 08:44 AM
  2. Elves
    By Sorontar in forum Main
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 06-25-2009, 04:04 AM
  3. 3/4 Elves
    By SlaveofAzrai in forum The Royal Library
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 05-30-2005, 09:12 PM
  4. Half-Elves (Was: dms on elves)
    By Trizt in forum MPGN Mailinglist archive 1996-1999
    Replies: 8
    Last Post: 11-20-1997, 01:53 PM
  5. re: Elves
    By RMoraza@aol.co in forum MPGN Mailinglist archive 1996-1999
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 09-25-1997, 04:05 PM

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  
BIRTHRIGHT, DUNGEONS & DRAGONS, D&D, the BIRTHRIGHT logo, and the D&D logo are trademarks owned by Wizards of the Coast, Inc., a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc., and are used by permission. ©2002-2010 Wizards of the Coast, Inc.