Chap 5 - How Should RP be gained?

[tcharazazel]

Why would you want to see how people have voted before you do anyway? Can't you make up your own mind?

[RaspK_FOG]

First of all, logging in as a guest, seeing how things are so far and then voting defeats the whole idea of voting. It is like saying: "I don't do what I like, I just like siding with the winners!" If you feel proud of such an accomplishment, be our guest (pun intented)...

As for the poll, I have to say that I like skills best, but using class features is a bood point in any case. An idea would be that a noble can choose from a list of class features to get, one of which is providing a competence to RP-producing skills.

[irdeggman]

Just for the record I voted for the skill based system. I've always liked it best but was basing my case on the discussion that ocurred a long time ago concerning the issue. This is the first vote though so hopefully it will put an end to the discussion, well at least as far as what should be in the BRCS not what people think.

[The Jew]

In defence of those poor slobs whose character has been attacked in this discussion :P . If I have a predecided position on an issue I would just vote, then look at results. If I am undecided and need time to think, I would want to see the poll results out of idle curiousity.

[irdeggman]

OK it is time to close this poll. Here are the results:


How should RP be gained?
1) Using a skill-based system (see BRCS-playtest for an example) [ 13 ] [61.90%]
2) Using a class-based system (see the 2nd ed BRRB for 2nd ed style example) [ 6 ] [28.57%]
3) Something else (Please specify) [ 2 ] [9.52%]
4) Abstain (or I don't really care) [ 0 ] [0.00%]


So it looks like RP should be gained using a skill-based system (more than 2 to one).