Search:

Type: Posts; User: tcharazazel; Keyword(s):

Page 1 of 15 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.03 seconds.

  1. Poll: So, does the Contest action require the regent...

    So, does the Contest action require the regent have troops to perform it?

    Of course not, so why are you insisting that it can be violent? The regent merely has to exert political influence, ie...
  2. Poll: And yet you are saying that fortifications can...

    And yet you are saying that fortifications can then have an effect on both, as fortifications will then affect the domain level by adding a bonus to domain contest actions and to large scale combat...
  3. Poll: I'm saying that by opening the door to allowing...

    I'm saying that by opening the door to allowing something like fortifications effect influence significantly enough on a provincial scale to justify a bonus, than something that already has such an...
  4. Poll: In that case Gary are you then as RP and good...

    In that case Gary are you then as RP and good skills are no longer the only factors for contesting, then what about for military actions against holdings? Should we then allow RP to influence such...
  5. Poll: Heheh, you seem really intent on creating this...

    Heheh, you seem really intent on creating this new contest province action then? I mean why are you bringing up province fortifications into a discussion about holding fortifications?

    The...
  6. Poll: Well, the influence you have is over all of the...

    Well, the influence you have is over all of the people who live in the province... and from what you just said for the fortifications to have any effect than all of the people would be needing to...
  7. Poll: Raesene, I agree completely.

    Raesene,

    I agree completely.
  8. Poll: Hmm... so far it looks almost 50/50, which MAKES...

    Hmm... so far it looks almost 50/50, which MAKES NO SENSE!?!?!?!? At least to me, but then maybe some of the people have forgotten all of the other rules, ie grid size and average unit size that...
  9. Replies
    32
    Views
    6,812

    Darkon, If you want to argue that elven realms...

    Darkon,

    If you want to argue that elven realms deserve to not have the 1 to 1 loss, then you need to try an argument more like this:



    Is the level of the province for elven realms...
  10. Replies
    19
    Views
    4,688

    Poll: I agree that you ought to put in the Atlas those...

    I agree that you ought to put in the Atlas those region specific prestige classes and keep the generics to the BRCS or supplements.
  11. Replies
    19
    Views
    4,688

    Poll: I agree that you ought to put in the Atlas those...

    I agree that you ought to put in the Atlas those region specific prestige classes and keep the generics to the BRCS or supplements.
  12. Replies
    8
    Views
    2,329

    Gladiators

    I imagine that Aduria and the Vos would have such arenas if anyone would.

    In the game I've been playing (though its been on hold for a long while now as some other groups catch up) I built a...
  13. Osprey and I had set up a system that was clearly...

    Osprey and I had set up a system that was clearly defined as I had ambitions of taking over Aduria and in order to do so I would need to have a set hierarchy.

    I have it on my website (which hasn't...
  14. Replies
    19
    Views
    6,833

    Actually, if they are intelligent PCs then they...

    Actually, if they are intelligent PCs then they easily could, for example if the job was done very professionally, ie almost none, if any clues left behind so it looks like the HMA just may have...
  15. Replies
    33
    Views
    8,928

    Actually, after talking with Osprey about the Q&D...

    Actually, after talking with Osprey about the Q&D system, we thought about getting rid of the multipliers and replacing them with flat bonuses. Unfortunately, I haven't had enough free time to write...
  16. Replies
    33
    Views
    8,928

    Well A_Dark, if you look at the numbes, the DC to...

    Well A_Dark, if you look at the numbes, the DC to train a unit to crack will be 10+2x30=70. As this is generally a low end game, who will likely have a high enough lead skill to ever train up a unit...
  17. Replies
    13
    Views
    4,185

    Actually, if you keep your gold in that holding...

    Actually, if you keep your gold in that holding then yes it is worth it to fortify it. Though I cant really think of another reason.
  18. Replies
    33
    Views
    8,928

    So, are you saying that we should keep the unit...

    So, are you saying that we should keep the unit training and do away with unit exp essentially? Then how much training can a unit recieve? Is it still just 2 training options or can the units melee...
  19. Replies
    33
    Views
    8,928

    Actually, I believe it was you, irdeggman, who...

    Actually, I believe it was you, irdeggman, who mentioned putting the complex system into a supplemental. Hence, one of my reason for stating we ought to finish it. The other main reason being that I...
  20. Replies
    33
    Views
    8,928

    Heheh, Ok, so if we plan on including a complex...

    Heheh, Ok, so if we plan on including a complex version of the battle system and the simple version is going to be based on that, why not first work on the complex system and get is as accurate as we...
  21. Replies
    33
    Views
    8,928

    Cool, just wanted a clarification of what you...

    Cool, just wanted a clarification of what you meant by complex vs simple then. It seems like a more simplified version of Osprey's battle system then.

    Well, it maybe hard for him to cut his...
  22. Replies
    33
    Views
    8,928

    Heheh, as the target market will not likely be as...

    Heheh, as the target market will not likely be as interested in detailed battles that follow logical rules based on a mix of D&D rules and real medievel battles, it is likely that using the simple...
  23. Ok, as stacking is pretty much covered, lets move...

    Ok, as stacking is pretty much covered, lets move on to the 2nd topic: Magic on the Battle Field.

    I voted for use of all three types during a battle. My reasoning being that it defies all logic...
  24. Replies
    3
    Views
    1,777

    Seneschal? Do you have a link for that program?...

    Seneschal? Do you have a link for that program? For if it is easier at keeping records than Word and Excel, it would be a blessing.

    Thanks
  25. I voted no before and with the closing of those...

    I voted no before and with the closing of those polls, I stand with that decision with this new info. It certainly doesn't seem logical to keep stacking looking at the statistics we've sanctioned.
    ...
Results 1 to 25 of 366
Page 1 of 15 1 2 3 4
BIRTHRIGHT, DUNGEONS & DRAGONS, D&D, the BIRTHRIGHT logo, and the D&D logo are trademarks owned by Wizards of the Coast, Inc., a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc., and are used by permission. ©2002-2010 Wizards of the Coast, Inc.