Sorontar
11-09-2009, 03:25 AM
I came across reference in the BR wiki to a place called St Albans (http://www.birthright.net/brwiki/index.php/First_Battle_of_St_Albans). Initially I wondered whether this place originated in published works or not. But then I realised that there might be a bigger issue here.
And that is the use of terms like "saint" in Cerilia. In RL, a religious "saint" is only termed as such within the Catholic Church (my quick research tells me) when referring to an exceptional person. Some other religious groups (e.g. Mormons) use the term widely for members of their community. People like Mohammed, Moses and Abraham I have heard be referred to as prophets, not saints.
So what should Cerilia use? Prophets and saints? Is it all just in the "translation"? What about place names like St Albans? Who would decide who is a prophet or a saint? A single temple? All temples of a particular god? All priests? Particular nationalities? Non-temple regents? For example, what is Fitzalan (the blessed) considered to be?
Sorontar
ps. I did a quick look through the forums but the previous discussions always seem to be talking about RL saints, not Cerilian ones.
And that is the use of terms like "saint" in Cerilia. In RL, a religious "saint" is only termed as such within the Catholic Church (my quick research tells me) when referring to an exceptional person. Some other religious groups (e.g. Mormons) use the term widely for members of their community. People like Mohammed, Moses and Abraham I have heard be referred to as prophets, not saints.
So what should Cerilia use? Prophets and saints? Is it all just in the "translation"? What about place names like St Albans? Who would decide who is a prophet or a saint? A single temple? All temples of a particular god? All priests? Particular nationalities? Non-temple regents? For example, what is Fitzalan (the blessed) considered to be?
Sorontar
ps. I did a quick look through the forums but the previous discussions always seem to be talking about RL saints, not Cerilian ones.